Researchers Excited,
But Many Farmers
Are Still Skeptical
BY BOB
HURLEY
COLUMNIST
Switchgrass is
still a relatively new term and a largely unknown crop among Greene County farmers.
But East Tennessee agricultural researchers say they will be converting
switchgrass into fuel before the end of the year.
"The biorefinery at
Vonore is scheduled to begin production of cellulosic ethanol by the middle of December," said Dr.
Kelly Tiller, president and chief executive officer of the Knoxville-based General Energy Corp.,
LLC.
Dr. Tiller, a former tobacco policy analyst at the University of
Tennessee, was named to her new position last year after the Tennessee government, the University of
Tennessee, the U.S. Department of Energy, and DuPont Danisco Cellulosic Ethanol Corp., LLC, began
partnering to pioneer the process of turning grass into gas.
"We are
pleased with every phase of the project," Dr. Tiller said of the mammoth and complex effort aimed at
reducing U.S. dependence on imported energy.
"We are making progress on
all fronts," she went on, "from growing the switchgrass to the research of turning it into a
renewable fuel."
Dr. Tiller added that all phases of the construction of
the biorefinery are "on track," and that enthusiasm over the entire project remains
high.
"This project represents a tremendous opportunity for agriculture
in Tennessee," she said.
Asked when the farmers of Greene County and
other counties of Northeast Tennessee might become involved in the actual production of switchgrass,
Dr. Tiller said the answer would be "pure speculation."
Timelines for the
project are difficult to formulate, she said, but she thinks that switchgrass will be a viable
option for most Tennessee farmers in less than 10 years.
Other
researchers connected with the huge project basically agree with the "10 years or sooner" timeline,
but many Greene County farmers fear the movement will come too late to help them out of the hole
that the current agricultural economy has put them in.
MORE RESEARCH
NEEDED
"We might be just three to five years away from our first
commercial biorefinery in the state," said Ken Goddard, extension biofuels specialist at
UT.
"But we've got to be careful here and not get the cart in front of
the horse," he said.
"The horse, in this case, is the research that is
going to give us the answers on how to convert grass to gas. It takes time to develop answers. It is
as simple at that."
But the "10 years or sooner" timeline that Goddard
and others have been talking about for some time is "still a good number," he says, in terms of how
long it could take to make switchgrass a household word in all 95 counties of the
state.
Rob Ellis, director of the UT Research and Education Center of
Greeneville, who is involved in the switchgrass research project on a limited scale, thinks farmers
in this part of the state will be seeing opportunities develop in five years or
less.
"I think we will be seeing a major difference in the big picture of
bioenergy in the next five years," Ellis said this week while surveying the center's research plots
of switchgrass.
"If other countries can convert a renewable resource such
as switchgrass to fuel, then surely the U.S. can do it," he said.
"Here
at the Center, we've demonstrated that switchgrass can be successfully grown in our part of the
state, but, just like all other crops, there are some challenges," Ellis
said.
"The main difficulty we have found with switchgrass," he explained,
"is the germination of the seed itself. Our plots have done well once we get germinaton, but
switchgrass takes a long time to germinate."
LONG DISTANCE TO
VONORE
Even before the constuction of the biorefinery at Vonore began
last year, farmers in Greene County knew they were out of the production loop because of the
distance involved.
Early on in planning for the biorefinery, a 50-mile
circle was drawn around Vonore, with all the initial switchgrass coming from within the
circle.
Vonore is almost 40 miles southwest of Knoxville, a location
which meant that farmers in this end of the state would be only spectators during the early stages
of what some are calling "the biofuels revolution in Tennessee."
"Our
farmers felt a little left out," said Tony Bird, president of the Greene County Farm Bureau, "and
rightfully so."
Because of the 50-mile rule in producing switchgrass for
the biorefinery, Bird says he has seen little-to-no interest in the crop in Greene County for the
time being.
"We were too far up the road," Bird smiled, "so they cut us
off. There just isn't that much interest in switchgrass in Greene County right
now."
Asked if he knew of any switchgrass-growers in this part of the
state, Bird initially said that he didn't.
"But let me chew on that a
minute," he said. "Surely, there must be at least one switchgrass grower out there
somewhere."
Less than half an hour later, Bird called back to report that
there is at least one in Greene County.
"There's a farmer out near
Limestone named Mike Alexander who is doing a good job with some switchgrass hay," Bird
said.
COUNTY FARMER INVOLVED
"My
interest in switchgrass begins and ends with hay," Alexander said when contacted at his home near
the Davy Crockett Birthplace State Park.
"It is very good to me as hay.
The cows love it, and I don't have to spend a dime on fertilizer for it," he
said.
Switchgrass is a warm-season perennial grass that is native to much
of this country. Alexander said he favors it and other warm-season grasses over fescue, the most
common pasture and hay crop in East Tennessee.
Fescue, however, is a
cool-season grass that provides very limited forage during the hottest months of the
year.
Dr. Gary Bates, professor of plant science at the University of
Tennessee, says switchgrass can indeed out-produce some other forages, especially
fescue.
"Switchgrass that is grown for forage can produce up to twice as
much feed as fescue. That's pretty impressive by any standard," Bates said from his Knoxville office
this week.
In addition to its primary use as a biomass, Tiller, Goddard
and other researchers in the biofuels project have said repeatedly that farmers should look at
"other uses and other opportunities with switchgrass."
For Alexander, who
emphasizes that growing switchgrass for a biorefinery is not part of his future plans, the emergence
of switchgrass as a forage crop came along at precisely the right
time.
"Fertilizer prices were going out the roof, and cattle prices were
coming down," Alexander said. "I needed to find something to cut expenses in a
hurry.
"I had experimented with some other warm-season grasses, and while
I liked them fine, switchgrass was easier for me to drill into the ground, and my germination rate
was excellent.
"While I have had very good success with switchgrass, I
have absolutely no plans to ever grow it for anything other than hay for my
cattle."
NOT THAT HOPEFUL
Other
farmers fear they will be "too old or too broke" to take advantage of the move to
switchgrass.
"I'll be dead or broke by the time switchgrass comes to
Chuckey," said Lowell Wayne Brown, one of East Tennessee's largest tobacco- and
grain-growers.
"As for me and my house, we will stick with tobacco and
corn and soybeans as long as they pay the bills," Brown said. "Tobacco, in spite of all you've heard
and read, is still the main thing when it comes to dollars returned per
acre.
"I'm just not the least bit optimistic that switchgrass will ever
be a part of my farming plan."
Butch Shaw, who continues to expand his
farming operations at Mohawk, fears that he, too, will not be a good soldier in the biofuels
revolution being forecast.
"It sounds like another fad to me," said Shaw,
"and I've never gotten too excited over fads."
Because of his capability
to grow a large amount of corn and other grain crops, Shaw has become established as a major
supplier of livestock feed for other farmers in western Greene
County.
"I'm going to stick with what works for me," he
said.
A number of smaller farmers were contacted as part of the research
for this story, and in spite of the attention and resources that the biofuels movement is receiving
in Tennessee at this time, none of them reported an interest in growing switchgrass, or even
learning more about it.
BRAZIL'S EXPERIENCE
"We hope to trump all the criticism with the research first and then with the
production of fuel," said Goddard, who remains one of the leading cheerleaders for the project in
the state.
"This can be done," he said. "Look at Brazil. They did it. Why
can't we do it?"
Brazil, he pointed out, has become almost totally
energy-independent after an aggressive approach to the production of ethanol and biodiesel
fuel.
Goddard continued, "My job is to work with the farmers of East
Tennessee in order to produce the biomass needed for a project of this
scope.
"I am very optimistic that our farmers can do their part and that
our chemists can get the research done, and we can lessen our dependence on foreign
energy.
"But this is a brand-new industry, and we're still trying to get
it kick-started."
Goddard added, "It is very big and very worthwhile. We
must not stop until we are able to fill our tanks with a product that we can grow ourselves every
year.
"And we must not fail."